I ordered a 3x and they were a bit too big-still wearable though. I then ordered the 2x and they are perfect. They fit nice, feel comfortable, and are holding up with washing so far. I did order from 2 other companies to see which ones I liked best. I am making the switch to boxers. The other companies are ok, but Culprit is my favorite so far. I will be ordering more! I do like the mystery pair because it is less expensive. I still have some sticker shock from the cost, but if they last then it will be worth it.